Top 7 Best Invisible Dog Fences
Editors Top Choice
Best Perimeter Fence
Best Runner Up -In Ground Fence
Do you have a dog that likes to roam too much and doesn't want to listen to your commands at all? Perhaps you have one of those that like to destroy flowers in your garden or to swim in the pool? You might wonder what is the best solution for a dog who, because of his nature, might cause a traffic accident or be a victim of one. It's always better to prevent these things than to regret and face the consequences. Now you're thinking: "Hey, I've tried some conventional solutions and it didn't go well. Is there a better way to stop that from happening?"
Well, there are multiple ways to limit your dog's movement range, some of them more efficient than others. Not every owner can afford to put a cage in his yard or a high fence around his garden. Also, some of the options are expensive, yet don't provide an adequate solution to your problem. There is, however, one that might be exactly what you're looking for. That's right, the invisible dog fence. Keep reading to find out more and see which options we recommend as the best invisible dog fences.
Benefits of Using an Invisible Dog Fence
Relatively small cost – no need to worry about the price, as these fences don't cost as much as traditional fences. Not only that, the best invisible dog fences require almost no maintenance at all. They don't need to be repaired, re-painted, or replaced, which is quite convenient and saves you a lot of money. The only thing they do require is battery replacement.
No view obstruction – Traditional wooden or metal fences might take up a lot of space and block the view of your beautiful garden or backyard. Unlike that, the invisible pet fence is buried underground or wireless. You only need to plant a perimeter of wire around the selected zone and strap a transmitter to your dog's collar. What you get now is an invisible barrier that only your dog notices. Some owners like to put flags around their yard to indicate the borders.
Flexibility and convenience – Since the best invisible dog fences do not use a physical barrier, it provides more flexibility than the traditional fence. You may put the fence wherever you desire; you're not limited only to your yard area. If you already have an ordinary fence, but your dog has found some way around it, simply place the electric fence around the traditional one to prevent any future escapes.
Difference between wireless and in-ground fences – Wireless fences use a radio transmitter which allows for a determined radius of movement within. These fences are particularly good if you move it regularly and don’t have a more permanent area, but they might not be the best option if you want to keep your dog out of the pool or a certain area within the yard.
In-ground fences are more difficult to install, but they can be customized to a greater extent. They are a perfect solution if your yard doesn't have a regular shape or if you want to keep the dog out of a specific area. They are more stable than the wireless ones and if you prefer defined boundaries, then you should check these out. However, better prepare a shovel because you'll need to get digging.
BEST WIRELESS DOG FENCES
PetSafe is a renowned company that makes pet fence solutions. One of their finest wireless-type fences is PetSafe Wireless Fence Pet Containment System. It has stood the test of time and no matter how many other fences hit the market, this one continues to be the top choice. Coupled with the fact that it's a cost-effective alternative to ordinary fences, this portable fence can be set up in one to two hours.
It comes with a single collar and a few extra batteries which can be found online when the time for replacement comes. This fence is characterized by a modifiable level of correction, with five levels of static correction and a tone-only mode for trained dogs who are familiar with saying within the allowed boundaries. The transmitter's range is 90 feet and can be easily moved to ensure flexibility and convenience. It is the ideal solution for a property that's around 200x200 feet. Basically, it has a radius 180 feet, which is a great range if you ask us.
As with every wireless dog fence, this one is also limited to a circular shaped boundary. If you're not careful during the setup, the system's range can be blocked and open up a few dead spots where your dog can pass through.
We advise you to test it yourself and make sure that nothing is interfering with the signal by taking the collar around the edge. It seems that every wireless fence has these kinds of problems, but the flaws are neglectable when you take into consideration the wide range. Just don't forget to prepare extra batteries just in case and to check the boundary for dead spots. In the end, we can truly recommend this PetSafe fence if you decide to go with a wireless option, as the majority of people have found it useful and effective at keeping their beloved pet safe.
- Easy to install and use
- Waterproof transmitter and receivers
- Immense range
- Five levels of shock
- Batteries are rare
- Minor problems with dead spots
Since 1991, PetSafe has been determined to make great products for your furry friends. It can be noticed by the customer reviews mentioning their outstanding customer service and will to help their customers in every way possible. Our second-to-best choice for wireless fences is the PetSafe PIF00-12917 Stay & Play, one of the newest dog fence additions from PetSafe. This one, among other things, offers a somewhat larger coverage area than it's predecessor (which is next on our list), and it's effective for smaller dogs. The Stay and Play can be set up quickly and easily moved from one place to another. You can use it to contain your pet anywhere.
The wireless range of the Stay & Play wireless fence is around 105 feet in most favorable conditions, and it fits almost any type of dog. Several options are available for this system, including the addition of multiple collars - a great solution if you have more than one dog.
The system can be set up easily and has one of the most powerful signals available. The collar battery can last for almost three weeks, but no worries. They are rechargeable so you won't be needing to buy something special every time to keep the system running. The charging adapter can charge two collars at once. In addition to that, you will also get 50 boundary training flags to visually mark the area where your dog can safely dwell.
Some users have complained about the fluctuating boundary line, but as we stated before, it happens with most of the wireless best invisible dog fences. Furthermore, if you have a metal roof on your house, it might interfere with the signal. We advise you to consult experts before buying a wireless fence. Overall, this is one of the best wireless dog fences around.
- Stable transmitter and huge range
- Rechargeable collar batteries
- Supports multiple dogs
- 5 levels of static correction, plus a tone-only mode for training
- Suitable for dogs 5+ pounds
- Collars work with neck sizes from 6-23 inches
- Metal proximity can disrupt the signal
- Fluctuating boundary line
As we said before, the next on our list is PIF-300 wireless dog fence system. It is slightly worse than it's successor, that we talked about, but more expensive. Nevertheless, this system has proved time and again to be reliable in doing what it does best. The PIF-300 comes with a 180-foot diameter, transmitting a circular boundary wirelessly, much like the number one on our list. It features five levels of adjustment to easily fit most dog sizes.
The one thing that makes this system exceptional is the setup simplicity. All you have to do is plug it in, adjust the radius level and it's good to go.
Because of that, many satisfied customers use this product for camping trips or vacation homes. Like all wireless systems, this one suffers from metal proximity. Also, the dead spots are no stranger to this system. You might reconsider placing it around cars or near a house with metal roof. We advise you to test it yourself and look for signal malfunctions.
Perhaps the main downside of PIF-300 is that batteries seem to deplete much quicker than the other products the PetSafe offers, mostly because it's an older system. In spite of that, this one has been a crowd favorite for a long time, being cheap and quality at the same time. If you can put up with the more frequent battery replacements this is the top budget solution for multiple dogs. Stock up with batteries and you're on your way.
- Two collars
- Fast and simple installation - no wires
- Comes with training manual
- 180 foot diameter range (1/2)
- Batteries deplete quickly
- Older system
- Suffers from metal proximity
BEST IN-GROUND INVISIBLE DOG FENCE
The eXtreme dog fence is essentially a DIY kit with a strong transmitter which allows the confinement of an unlimited number of dogs. The second generation's basic kit can cover an enormous area of 23-25 acres, with the possibility of extended coverage. It comes with three antennas and 12 battery checks. This fence can be set in any layout design and you have many options as to how and where to set it up. It is 100% customizable.
The system features updated electronics compatible with new collars and actually comes with a waterproof one. As they stated, it can be submerged to 100 feet. So if you have a pond that your dog might get into, this is an ideal option. Now you can let him swim freely and without worries. There is another cool feature with the eXtreme dog fence system. Not only it can contain dogs, but cats also. You just need to make sure your feline members have their own adequate collars. Furthermore, the system includes a receiver that can train your pets using vibration stimulation, as well as static and sound. One beep will be enough to let your pets know that they should back off.
In most in-ground fence systems, companies tend to include a 20 gauge wire. That is not the case with this one. This system comes with a 14 gauge wire, an extremely thick professional grade wire. As we already stated the fence configuration is 100% customizable. You can set up the wires however you like and the system will respond properly. Overall, you will be definitely satisfied with the eXtreme dog fence system, as most customers are. The thick wires, customizable collars and the ability to cover large areas definitely seal the deal with this one.
One of the best features of the eXtreme Dog Fence system is its lightweight and comfortable collar. Weighing in at only 1.1 ounces, the receiver collar is perfect for dogs anywhere from 8 pounds and up. In regards to comfort, the eXtreme rises above the rest. This is because its contact points are covered in a soft rubber covering. These Comfort Contacts™ stop the metal points from rubbing into your dog’s neck.
- Design flexibility
- Waterproof receiver collar
- Suitable for small to extra-large dogs
- Thick 14 gauge wire
- Can contain an unlimited amount of dogs
- Up to 10 acres of coverage
- Doesn't include a manual
- Collars lack quality control sometimes
The SportDog SDF-100A is a fence system for large properties. It can cover up to 100 acres. When it comes to this type of fences, The SDF-100A has always been a great option, with a sturdy waterproof collar that features a vibration warning. It can support an unlimited number of dogs, you just need to buy more collars. On the other hand, the collar is one of the biggest and bulkiest out there. It doesn't fit small dogs that well. The collar is very noticeable even if you put it on a bigger dog. If you want to check if the collar is working, this SportDog system features a basic tester tool.
As for the wiring, you get the 1,000 feet of boundary wire with the basic system, twice as much as other systems provide. If you want to expand, you will have to buy more wires and flags. By expanding the range, your canine will have a lot of space to roam freely. Just make sure to make all the necessary preparations and measures before you begin.
With the basic system, you usually get a 20-gauge wire. However, it can be upgraded to match your needs. If you want a professional grade wire, opt for the 14-gauge. With that option, both the wire and the insulation are four times stronger, making them more durable and less likely to break.
If you face a smaller installation, it is advisable to upgrade the wire. The modest investment is definitely worth it and will greatly reduce the risk of breaking.
In case you wonder if this system has more correction levels, the answer is yes, it does. Multiple correction levels are available to make sure you know exactly how to adjust it to suit your dog. The SDF-100A comes with another great feature, a wire break alarm. You will immediately be notified if something happens to your wires. For our final word, we would like to say that this is the best system for larger installations. Its reliability, coupled with the durable collars and the two-year warranty make it a great choice.
- Included coverage area up to 1.33 acres, expandable up to 100 acres
- Strong and durable collars
- 4 levels of correction and collar vibration feature
- Supports unlimited number of collars
- Not suitable for smaller dogs
- Collar battery is not rechargeable
The PetSafe YardMax is a rechargeable in-ground fence for both cats and dogs. This fence system can cover up to 1/3 of an acre. We know it's not that much but it's enough for your pets to play safely when you're not around. That's why the PetSafe YardMax is intended mainly for those who don't have a huge property. It can, however, be expanded up to ten acres, which is not bad at all.
Furthermore, the system helps to contain a wide range of dogs. The receiver collar, it's rechargeable and waterproof. It only needs two to three hours to be fully charged. It includes five levels of shock and a sound alert to make sure your pet stays within the boundaries, once properly trained.
The PetSafe YardMax comes with a unique feature that distinguishes it from other systems. It can be used in two ways: the YardMax Mode and the Boundary Zone. The first one contains a warning zone beginning from the other side of the boundary.
This means the shock only activates after the dog has stepped over the fence and provides a much wider playground for your pets. On the other side, the Boundary Zone is much like a traditional invisible fence. In this mode, the boundary starts from the in-ground wire and warns your dog as he approaches the fence. The wiring is easy to set up and consists of a tough 20 gauge wire. Though not a professional grade, it's still thick and strong, providing a well-protected fence under the ground. In the end, the YardMax is a bit more expensive compared to other fences on our list and some users have complained that it was hard for them to override the alarm. Nevertheless, it shines on smaller properties where the first mode can be fully utilized, giving your pets more space to roam.
- Features two unique modes
- Waterproof and rechargeable collar
- Uses tone and static correction
- Quick charging; can last up to 3 weeks
- For dogs 5+ pounds
- More wire is required for expansion
- Problems with alarm override
The final entry on our list is the PetSafe basic in-ground fence. It's an entry-level fence and is much cheaper than the new models. In spite of that, this fence is a great product with a bunch of features, otherwise, it wouldn't be featured on our list. The system allows for full customization and provides your dogs with 1/3 of an acre space capacity. If that's not enough and your dog needs more space, it can be expanded up to five acres with additional flags and wires.
The downside of this system is that the wire connections aren't that great. However, it can be fixed with a waterproof tape and some wire nuts.
Additionally, the PetSafe basic fence includes an adjustable receiver collar that can fit many neck sizes. It features four levels of shock and a beep-only mode, which is good for dogs in training. This system comes with another cool feature: namely, it includes an anti-linger prevention, thus preventing the dog from staying in the warning zone for too long. Unfortunately, the collar isn't strong enough for larger dogs. Despite that, if you have calm and well-behaved dogs, this would be a good solution for you. It has all the necessary features for a much lower price.
- Extremely affordable
- Accurate boundary covers 1/3 acre, expandable up to 5 acres
- Anti-linger feature
- Low-battery warning
- 4 correction levels, plus a tone-only mode for training
- Collar is not strong enough for larger breeds
- Takes time to install
Wireless Vs In Ground Dog Fences
An invisible dog fence is, without doubt, an exceptional way of keeping the dogs contained, yet free to roam and play safely. The great advantage these systems provide is that you don’t need to constantly keep an eye out for your dogs. Just put the collars around their necks, power up the transmitter and enjoy your free time while they enjoy theirs. There are two types of invisible dog fences – wireless and in-ground, both effective in their own way. Of course, there are some differences between the two. It’s not the case of price and effectiveness – both dog fencing systems offer great value for an affordable price, particularly when you compare them to physical fences which cost much more to install. However, there are a number of crucial factors that will help you decide which one is right for you. Keep reading to find out more about wireless vs in ground dog fences.
How Do Electric Dog Fences Work?
Wireless: This type of fencing system operates by giving the static shocks every time the receiver collar loses the signal from the transmitter. That’s why the transmitter has to be in the middle of the zone. It forms a perfect circle around the center and you can adjust the radius however you want. When the dog leaves the perimeter he gets the correction.
In-ground: With this system, the receiver collar is activated every time it picks up the signal from the boundary wire. When your dog gets close to the buried wire, a sound starts emitting from the collar giving him a warning. If he gets too close he will get a correction. That means with the in-ground fences the collar is activated inside the zone, and with the wireless fences, the collar is activated outside the zone.
The landscape of a property can greatly affect the function of invisible dog fences. An in-ground fence contains the pet in a different way than a wireless one does. The determining factor of how much area can the system cover is the transmitter. The more powerful the transmitter, the more area it can cover.
Wireless: Usually, a wireless fence can spread its signal over a maximum of 25 acres. That might be the main difference between the two systems because an in-ground fence can cover more than 100 acres. The wireless transmitter needs to have a direct line of sight to prevent the signal loss. This is the reason why wireless fences shine on wide open space without obstructions.
Another thing to keep in mind is that metal can interfere with the wireless signal. If you have any metal sheds in your yard or some kind of metal structure, the wireless system might have some consistency problems. Basically, anything that interrupts the signal will cause the receiver collar to activate, be it a metal siding or a hill. That means your dog gets the correction even though they didn’t cross the line.
In-ground: Usually the in-ground fence system is used when you want to have a stationary area and don’t plan to move it in the future. It can cover more than 100 acres, but you will have to buy additional wire for that purpose. This type of fence doesn’t have a problem with signal interference since its entire boundary wire is buried and independent on the environment. As you can see, the shape of your yard and obstructions on your property play an important role in determining which type of fencing system suits you.
Invisible Dog Fence Installation Difficulty
Wireless: Without a doubt, the main reason wireless fences are so popular is that they can be set up and installed rather quickly. You can have it up and running in an hour and you can even take it on road trips or pretty much anywhere. The only condition is to have a power source for the transmitter.
In-ground: It’s a bit different with in-ground fences. You have to plan the layout in advance and then bury the boundary wire. Installing an in-ground fence system will definitely be more time-consuming. Even though it requires a lot of effort, almost everyone agrees that it’s worth the small sacrifice. You will end up with a perfect containment area for your yard. You can make it a weekend project to set up an in-ground fence. The amount of work will depend on the size of the property and the equipment you have access to.
See how the PetSafe PIF00-12917 Stay & Play Wireless Fence is installed in the video below:
What About the Maintenance on an Electric Dog Fencing?
Wireless: With only the transmitter and the receiver collar needing an occasional maintenance, wireless fences are practically maintenance free. Most of the time you’ll only have to worry about the collar. Replacing or recharging the battery will vary depending on the manufacturer. Sometimes you will have to replace the metal contact points and washers. Other than that, wireless fences do not require much attention.
In-ground: In addition to the routine collar maintenance we mentioned above, with this type of fence you will also have to deal with an important issue – repairing a boundary wire when it breaks. It’s a frustrating and time-consuming maintenance problem you will eventually have to face. You might be thinking “How can I find a break in such a long wire? It will take me days…” Luckily, there is a wire break locator, specially designed to help you find the break, but we advise you to be careful when buying one. People have mixed feelings about them – some said it was great, others think it was a waste of money.
The main difference between wireless and in-ground fences is the wire. If you don’t like the idea of having to bury those wires and/or have a smaller property, then the wireless one is definitely a better choice. On the other hand, if you want to make plans and set your containment borders precisely or have a huge property, then the in-ground fence is the way to go. Each system has its strengths and weaknesses and both will provide a great and affordable way to contain your dog. Since you just found out how they differ from one another, you will have an easier time choosing what’s best for you and your dog.
While taking your dog to a park can definitely improve his welfare, it is often more convenient to let them out to wander freely in the backyard. If you don't have a physical barrier set up around your home or if it's not enough to keep the dog contained, the best invisible dog fences are an optimal solution to keep him safe and free to roam. Invisible fences have many advantages over their wooden counterparts. Most of them don't require that many tools to install and can be set up quickly. Besides that, unlike traditional fences, the outline of invisible fences is not restricted by the yard's topography.
In this article, we sorted out the best solutions when it comes to best invisible dog fences. We pointed out the most important aspects of every system, as well as flaws, to help you decide. Still, there are some things that you should keep in mind. Plan ahead and measure your yard to determine how much range you need and whether to choose the wireless or in-ground fence. When choosing the right collar, it's important to consider your dog's habits, his character, and build. One more thing, don't expect miracles. Invisible dog fences are not miraculous devices that will turn a disobedient dog into a calm one overnight. It takes time and patience, as everything else in life does.